I hardly ever comment directly on other blog postings, least of all the Bedlam Brigade's insane ramblings, but I feel an exception should be made for yesterday's effort, entitled An Impromptu Meeting. In fact, I will go even further and take the risk of cross-contamination, by giving a link - you can find it
here.
This was written by one Phil Makepeace, one of their newer columnists, and one about whom little seems to be known. Indeed, as someone once unkindly said of a former TV presenter, young Phil seems to have risen without trace. Most of his blog offerings have concentrated on his own past failures as a player. He certainly does not seem to suffer from a surfeit of creative fecundity - lacking anything else to say, he was reduced to filling up one recent column by asking readers to contribute "amusing" anagrams of chessplayers' names, a rather transparent device which did, however, have the advantage of allowing him to fill up another column, with a selection of the truly side-splitting responses he received.
Not Phil Makepeace. Honest.
Anyway, for the benefit of those of you who cannot be bothered to read his effort of yesterday, the gist is as follows: he was called up a few days ago and asked to attend a presentation regarding a chess-based mobile phone app. It seems our Phil is regarded -apparently, not just by himself - as an expert on such matters. He duly went along, and was fed and watered with appropriate quantities of alcohol, as is the wont on such occasions, in return for offering his inestimable opinion on the app concerned. His host was Andrew Paulson, head of Agon, the man responsible for running FIDE's world championship cycle, who has grand plans to revolutionise the presentation of chess throughout the world.
Usually, on such occasions, one turns up, has a few glasses of wine, expresses one's view, then politely excuses oneself and returns home, especially if one is not desperately impressed with the product concerned. But not our Phil, however. Flushed with self-importance from having been invited in the first place, he evidently felt a burning need to inform the rest of the world, so he has now chosen to bite the hand that fed him, by writing an embittered piece about his host. Paulson, we are informed, is "a man with a Messiah complex, who speaks only in personal pronouns". He doesn't have "a damn (sic) clue" about the field he is involved in (unlike Phil himself - "I know my shit", he proudly informs us), but "disgorges revolutionary personal theories about it". He is also "discourteous" (though probably not so discourteous as to accept someone's hospitality at a private function and then write a public blog, telling the world what an asshole they are).
Not Phil Makepeace. Honest
Quite a litany of abuse, about a man who has done nothing more than invite one over for a few free glasses of wine and a plate of peanuts. One wonders what Paulson can have done to deserve such censure. It seems that he failed to give little Phil "proper answers", something which our fearless app-developer-turned-consumer-watchdog-turned-investigative-reporter was not taking lying down. "...I went into full Paxman mode", he informs us. I can only hope Mr Paulson has been able to access appropriate counselling, to help him overcome the trauma he must have suffered, at being subjected to the full intellectual rigour of forensic questioning from little Phil.
Of course, the inaptly-named Makepeace offers no evidence to back up his claims. Most experienced journalists would produce a few quotes, to substantiate allegations that a person "speaks only in personal pronouns", for example. They would probably also take the precaution of not making themselves a laughing stock, by using a veritably Reubenesque 14 perpendicular pronouns in their own three short final paragraphs. But self-awareness seems not to be Phil's strongpoint. "I am a chess player, a pundit and a chess consumer. I am both the target market and the commentator", he rages. "I am the Way, the Truth and the Light", I half expected him to add.
Not Phil Makepeace. Honest
Young Phil is clearly a man to watch. In his final sentence, he invites "everybody to be wary with me". Almost right - just change "with" to "of", and I'd have to agree.